Addressing the leading risk factors for ill health in England: Review of the UK government’s policy

Policies proposed by government in England since 2016 to address smoking, diet, physical activity and harmful alcohol use are summarised in Tables 1–4. Only some of these policies have been implemented, and policies in each area are linked to a mix of specific and overarching government targets (Box 1). Wider government targets have also been set that necessitate action on these risk factors – including a commitment to extend healthy life expectancy by 5 years by 2035, while narrowing the gap between the richest and poorest.

Policies on targeted risk factors also interact with other national policy and political decisions that shape social, economic, and environmental factors influencing people’s ability to adopt healthy behaviours., This includes, for example, spending decisions relating to public health, social security and the NHS; funding for local government services, such as housing; and economic decisions relating to taxation and pricing.

Box 1: National targets for each leading risk factor

Target

Government strategy

Responsible body

Smoking

Ambition to go ‘smoke-free’ by 2030, defined as a smoking prevalence of less than 5%

DHSC and Cabinet Office green paper: Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s  (July 2019)

DHSC and Cabinet Office

Reduce smoking prevalence among adults from 15.5% to 12% or less by the end of 2022

DH Tobacco Control Plan for England (July 2017)

DHSC; Public Health England (PHE) (now OHID); NHS England (NHSE); local systems (trusts/CCGs/LAs)

Reduce the proportion of 15-year-olds who regularly smoke from 8% to 3% or less by the end of 2022

DH Tobacco Control Plan for England (July 2017)

DHSC; PHE (now OHID)

Reduce inequalities in smoking prevalence between those in routine and manual occupations and the general population

DH Tobacco Control Plan for England (July 2017)

DHSC; PHE (now OHID); local systems: LAs/CCGs (now integrated care systems (ICSs))

Reduce prevalence of smoking in pregnancy from 10.7% to 6% or less by the end of 2022

DH Tobacco Control Plan for England (July 2017)

DHSC; PHE (now OHID); NHSE; local health systems

Physical activity

Ensure all children and young people have access to at least 60 minutes of physical activity every day (30 minutes at school and 30 minutes outside school)

School Sport and Activity Action Plan (July 2019)

Childhood obesity: a plan for action (2016)

Department for Education (DfE); Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS); DHSC

Childhood obesity

Halve childhood obesity by 2030 and significantly reduce the gap in obesity between children from the most and least deprived areas by 2030

Tackling obesity: government strategy (July 2020)

Childhood obesity: a plan for action, chapter 2 (June 2018)

DHSC

Harmful alcohol use

No national targets have been set to reduce harmful alcohol use

Smoking policy

Since the 1970s, the UK government has adopted a mix of population-level tax and regulatory policies alongside information campaigns and cessation services supporting individuals to quit smoking. Regarded as a global leader in tobacco control, the UK produced its first comprehensive tobacco strategy in 1998 and was one of the first countries to introduce smoke-free laws to protect people from secondhand smoke in public places and vehicles., Measures such as plain packaging and health warnings on packs have been introduced, and tobacco affordability has been reduced through escalating duty rates. Public support for government intervention to limit marketing and availability of tobacco is also high and has grown over time.,

While smoking rates have remained higher among those who are more disadvantaged, including those working in routine and manual occupations, overall smoking rates declined significantly since the government began to take action – from 46% in 1974 to 16% in 2019 (Figure 6).,

Source: ONS, Adult smoking habits, Health Foundation policy navigator and ASH: Key dates in the history of anti-tobacco campaigning and Timeline of tobacco tax increases in the UK.

Notes: Only results from 2000 are weighted, pre-2000 estimates are only available every 2 years.

The government’s most recent tobacco control plan for England (2017) did not extend this previous focus on national legislation and regulation, instead shifting towards individual-level interventions such as providing guidance to support smokers to quit. The plan set a range of targets designed to achieve the government’s vision of a ‘smoke-free generation’ in which adult smoking rates are 5% or lower. Specific targets were set for 2022 to reduce smoking prevalence among adults from 15.5% to 12% or less, and to reduce prevalence among people in routine and manual occupations, pregnant women, and 15-year-olds.

The interventions that support these targets are broad and focus on information provision – including promises to monitor trends, update national guidance and train health professionals to provide stop-smoking support. While there was a commitment to maintain high tobacco duty rates and make the prison estate in England smoke-free, no new tobacco regulations were introduced in the 2017 plan. Since publication of a 2018 delivery plan, which included some detail of progress against the 2017 tobacco control plan targets, little information tracking progress has been published.

A number of targeted individual-level policy interventions are also outlined in the NHS Long Term Plan (2019), focused on expanding access to stop-smoking services for inpatient populations, including pregnant women and people with mental ill health. While these initiatives have potential to provide valuable targeted support for these high-risk population groups, it is unclear whether funding will be adequate to meet demand. It is also not clear how service rollout will be prioritised across NHS trusts, particularly in the context of high ongoing NHS pressures and a growing elective care backlog.

The government’s prevention green paper – Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s (2019) – appeared to pave the way for a greater level of ambition around population-level smoking policy, including fiscal and regulatory interventions. A ‘smoke-free by 2030’ target was set and the need for bold action recognised. DHSC also committed to consider a ‘polluter pays’ approach, whereby the government would legislate to make tobacco manufacturers contribute towards the cost of tobacco control. Over 2 years later, however, the government is yet to publish a response to the green paper and there is little detail on how it intends to achieve the target. In addition, the government’s updated tobacco control plan for England remains unpublished despite an original release date of July 2021.

Table 1: Summary of major policy initiatives on smoking (2016–2021)

Policy initiative

Date

Strategy

Responsible body

Lever

Degree of agency and targeting

‘Polluter pays’ levy on tobacco industry

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s

DHSC and Cabinet Office

Regulation (fee)

Population-level; low agency

Implemented? No.

All people admitted to hospital who smoke offered NHS-funded tobacco treatment services by 2023/24

2019

NHS Long Term Plan

NHSE; local health systems (ICSs)

Service provision

Individual-level; high agency

Implemented? Underway.

Smoke-free pregnancy pathway for expectant mothers and their partners

2019

NHS Long Term Plan

NHSE; local health systems

Service provision

Individual-level; high agency; targeted at high-risk groups

Implemented? Underway.

Smoking cessation offer for long-term users of specialist mental health services

2019

NHS Long Term Plan

NHSE; local health systems

Service provision

Individual-level; high agency; targeted at high-risk groups

Implemented? Underway.

To achieve the targets set in the 2017 Tobacco Control Plan for England (see Box 1) a number of broad commitments were made, largely relating to funding and enforcement of existing policies. These included commitments to:

  • update national guidance
  • provide national monitoring and support for stop-smoking services
  • continue funding mass media campaigns
  • adopt measures to encourage e-cigarette use.

Policy to improve diet and address obesity

The government has introduced some policies aimed at rebalancing the food environment towards healthier options. Most notably, in 2018 the government introduced a levy on sugary drinks (the soft drinks industry levy). The levy has been successful in incentivising manufacturers to reformulate their products, leading to a fall in average sugar content in soft drinks of 29%, with high public support maintained.,,, The government’s 2020 obesity strategy also featured regulatory measures aimed at restricting marketing and advertising of unhealthy foods. This included restrictions on some products high in fat, salt or sugar (HFSS) being marketed on TV before 9pm and a ban on paid-for advertising online; restrictions on the promotion of some HFSS products in shops; and calorie labelling measures. All are set to come into force by the start of 2023.

Despite these steps forward – and the effectiveness of fiscal and regulatory measures introduced to tackle smoking – government action on obesity is still largely focused on changing individual behaviour. A recent review of UK government obesity strategies between 1992 and 2020 showed it has tended to favour policies that depend on individuals’ motivation and ability to engage with information and advice. Few fiscal or regulatory policies have been introduced aimed at directly shaping the choices available to individuals.

A central plank of the 2020 obesity strategy was a new ‘Better Health’ information campaign, based around an NHS 12-week weight loss plan app. As childhood obesity rates climbed through 2021, the government launched a series of pilots aimed at incentivising healthier eating and providing specialised weight management services. This included a ‘Health Incentives’ app rewarding participants for behaviours, such as eating more fruit and vegetables (piloted in Wolverhampton from early 2022), and the launch of 15 specialist NHS clinics for severely obese children.,

A number of recently proposed population-level policies to improve diets have also been cast aside, with a lack of follow-up and transparency after their announcement. Despite announcing a ban on the sale of energy drinks to those younger than 16 in the 2019 prevention green paper, the policy has not been implemented. Likewise, a commitment in 2018 to consider including sugary milk drinks within the SDIL has been abandoned, with the 2020 obesity strategy making no mention of either policy.

While a white paper responding to the 2021 National Food Strategy is yet to be published, early signs are not encouraging regarding government’s willingness to implement the fiscal and regulatory interventions recommended, such as a sugar and salt reformulation tax., The latest data also indicate that the government’s 2018 national childhood obesity target – to ‘halve childhood obesity and significantly reduce the gap in obesity between children from the most and least deprived areas by 2030’ – will be missed. In 2020, an inquiry by the House of Lords Select Committee on Food, Poverty, Health and the Environment concluded that a ‘unifying government ambition or strategy on food’ has been lacking, with a resulting lack of coordination and a dearth of coherent policies addressing interrelated issues such as poverty, food insecurity and poor health.

Table 2: Summary of policy initiatives on diet (2016–2021)

Policy initiative

Date

Strategy

Responsible body

Lever

Degree of agency and targeting

Sugar and salt reformulation tax

A number of other recommendations were made in the NFS, outlined more fully in Table 2 (Appendix)

2021

National Food Strategy (NFS)

Commissioned by Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Taxation

Population-level; low agency

Implemented? Government has promised to respond formally with a white paper within 6 months of the NFS’s publication.

Ban on high fat, sugar and salt (HFSS) products being shown on TV before 9pm

2020

Tackling Obesity: government strategy

DHSC

Regulation (marketing)

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Due to be implemented from the beginning of 2023. Does not cover all media where advertising could be time restricted such as cinema and radio.

Total online advertising restriction for HFSS products

2020

Tackling Obesity: government strategy

DHSC

Regulation (marketing)

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Due to implemented from the beginning of 2023. Does not cover brand advertising, owned content or advertising by small and medium-sized businesses.

Restrictions on promotion of unhealthy food and drinks in retail outlets and online

2020

Tackling Obesity: government strategy

DHSC

Regulation (marketing)

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Due to be introduced from October 2022.

Calorie labelling in large out-of-home sector businesses

2020

2018

Tackling Obesity: government strategy;

Childhood obesity: a plan for action, chapter 2

DHSC

Regulation (information provision)

Population-level, high agency

Implemented? Yes, regulations come into force from April 2022 (for large businesses with 250+ employees).

Front-of-pack nutrition labelling reforms (consultation)

2020

Tackling Obesity: government strategy

DHSC

Regulation (provision of information/warnings)

Population-level, high agency

Implemented? No consultation response published.

‘Better Health’ campaign

2020

Tackling Obesity: government strategy

DHSC

PHE (now OHID)

Information provision (mass media campaign)

Population-level, high agency

Implemented? Yes.

Expansion of diabetes prevention programme

2020

2019

Tackling Obesity: government strategy; NHS Long Term Plan

NHS England (NHSE)

Service provision; information

Individual-level, high agency, targeted at high-risk groups

Implemented? Yes.

National Infant Feeding Survey: reinstatement

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s

DHSC and Cabinet Office

Information

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? No.

Restricting sales of energy drinks to children younger than 16

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s; Childhood obesity: a plan for action, chapter 2

DHSC and Cabinet Office

Regulation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? No.

Primary care weight management services: Increasing access

2020

2019

Tackling Obesity: government strategy; NHS Long Term Plan

NHS England (NHSE); PHE (now OHID); local health systems

Service provision

Individual-level, high agency; targeted at high-risk groups

Implemented? Underway.

Adding milk drinks to the soft drinks industry levy (SDIL)

2018

Childhood obesity: a plan for action, chapter 2

DHSC

Taxation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? No.

Voluntary sugar reduction programme: Taking out 20% of sugar in products

2016

Childhood obesity: a plan for action

PHE (now OHID)

Voluntary programme

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Yes.

Soft drinks industry levy (SDIL)

2016

Sugar reduction: the evidence for action; Budget 2016

Public Health England (PHE); HM Treasury

Taxation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Yes.

Physical activity policy

The primary approach taken to improve physical activity has been information provision. DHSC publishes guidelines about the amount and type of physical activity people should undertake. The 2019 prevention green paper updated these guidelines for adults, alongside launching a physical activity campaign to support those living with health conditions to be more active. The government’s 2016 ‘plan for action’ on childhood obesity set a target that all children and young people should have access to at least 60 minutes of physical activity every day. This was reiterated in a Department for Education and DHSC school sport and activity action plan published in 2019. Little information has been published on progress against this target, and robust data are lacking to monitor and evaluate progress.

Beyond the role of DHSC, responsibility for increasing physical activity is split across a number of government departments: the Department for Culture, Media and Sport has overarching responsibility for sport, but physical activity is also covered by the Department for Education and the Department for Transport. As part of the Department for Culture, Media and Sport’s Sporting Future strategy (2015), Sport England announced £100m of funding for 12 local delivery pilots in 2017 to test new ways of encouraging communities, particularly those facing persistent inequalities, to increase their levels of physical activity. These pilots, which ran until September 2020 and were centred around a system-wide, place-based approach, do not appear to have been funded longer term or rolled out more widely.

The Department for Transport has also published a number of recent strategies designed to encourage active travel by improving cycling and walking infrastructure. This includes an investment strategy (2017) and a white paper setting out a ‘bold vision for cycling and walking’ (2020)., As part of this vision, £2bn of new funding to improve cycling and walking infrastructure was announced, as well as plans to incentivise GPs to prescribe cycling in places with poor health and low physical activity rates. In October 2021, the Net Zero strategy reiterated a target for half of all journeys in towns and cities to be cycled or walked by 2030. It is questionable whether the £2bn of new funding allotted to reach these targets is at the scale required to support a long-term shift towards active travel. Greater Manchester’s 1,800 mile cycling and walking network, for example, is estimated to cost £1.5bn on its own.,

Little has been published by government on the impact of its physical activity campaigns or GP prescribing initiatives. A recent inquiry conducted by the House of Lords National Plan for Sport and Recreation Committee found that government strategies relating to physical activity have been siloed, with cross-government work not happening at the scale required and fragmented delivery and funding systems. There has also been a focus on short-term projects and pilots, an approach that may hamper more meaningful long-term changes in activity levels.

Table 3: Summary of policy initiatives on physical activity (2016–2021)

Policy initiative

Date

Strategy

Responsible body

Lever

Degree of agency and targeting

New commissioning body and inspectorate: Active Travel England

2020

Gear Change: A bold vision for cycling and walking

Department for Transport

Regulation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Yes, launched in January 2022.

Incentivising GPs to prescribe cycling and building cycle facilities in towns with poor health

2020

Gear Change: A bold vision for cycling and walking

Department for Transport

Primary care networks (PCNs)

Service provision and regulation (subsidy)

Individual-level, high agency

Implemented? Not clear.

Supporting cycling and walking infrastructure – £2bn investment

2020

Gear Change: A bold vision for cycling and walking

Department for Transport

Funding and regulation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Yes, funding confirmed up to 2025.

‘Moving Healthcare Professionals’ national programme

2019

2017

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s; Moving Healthcare Professionals

PHE (now OHID) and Sport England

Information (mass media/campaign)

Individual-level, high agency

Implemented? Yes.

Physical activity campaign for people with health conditions

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s

DHSC and Sport England

Information (mass media/campaign)

Individual-level, high agency

Implemented? Not clear.

Local pilots testing new ways of delivering sustainable increases in activity levels

2017

Sporting Future: Second Annual Report

DCMS; Sport England

Funding

Mixture of tailored interventions

Implemented? Yes, £100m allocated over 4 years for 12 local delivery pilots (since Jan 2018).

Policy to address harmful alcohol use

No government strategy to address alcohol harm has been published since 2012. That strategy had promised a ‘radical change in approach’ and outlined a number of population-level, low agency interventions to ‘turn the tide against irresponsible drinking’. This included minimum unit pricing for alcohol, banning multi-buy alcohol promotions in shops, and regulating to ensure public health is considered as an objective by local authorities when making alcohol licensing decisions.

Soon after its publication, the government backtracked on all such policies. A decade on these have not been adopted, despite mounting evidence on the effectiveness of measures such as minimum unit pricing following its introduction in Scotland (2018) and Wales (2020)., Although government announced plans for a new alcohol strategy in May 2018, this was not produced. And instead of introducing measures to tackle harmful drinking in its 2019 prevention green paper, government chose to work with industry to promote low alcohol products. Alcohol does not feature as a priority as part of government’s prevention agenda, with no national targets set. No policies have been introduced in the previous 5 years other than a commitment to set up alcohol care teams in hospitals with high rates of alcohol-related admissions, and to launch ‘sobriety tags’ detecting whether offenders have broken drinking bans.,

Alcohol continues to be widely marketed – including online, on TV, in public spaces and as part of event sponsorships. This ignores evidence showing marketing directly influences alcohol consumption. While the Scottish government is planning to consult on measures to restrict alcohol marketing, no such measures are under consideration in England. Besides a recent commitment to consult on calorie labelling for alcoholic drinks and mandatory labelling of the Chief Medical Officer’s low-risk drinking guidelines, there has been a striking lack of action for something that is responsible for over 350,000 hospital admissions a year.

Table 4: Summary of policy initiatives on alcohol (2012–2021)

No national strategy to address harmful alcohol use has been produced since 2012.

Policy initiative

Date

Strategy

Responsible body

Lever

Degree of agency and targeting

Calorie labelling on alcoholic drinks

2020

Tackling obesity: government strategy

DHSC

Regulation (for provision of information)

Population-level, high agency

Implemented? Consultation promised.

Alcohol-free descriptor threshold increases

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s

DHSC

Regulation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Unclear.

Working with industry to increase availability of alcohol-free and low-alcohol products

2019

Advancing our health: prevention in the 2020s

DHSC

Voluntary programme

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? Unclear.

Alcohol Care Teams (ACTs)

2019

NHS Long Term Plan

NHSE

Service provision

Individual-level, high agency

Implemented? Underway/extent of rollout unclear.

Minimum unit pricing for alcohol

2012

The Government’s Alcohol Strategy

Home Office

Regulation (pricing)

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? No.

Ban on multi-buy promotions for alcohol in shops

2012

The Government’s Alcohol Strategy

Home Office

Regulation (marketing)

Population-level, medium agency

Implemented? No.

Health as a local alcohol licensing objective

2012

The Government’s Alcohol Strategy

Home Office

Regulation

Population-level, low agency

Implemented? No.


Tables 1–4 are adapted from a more detailed table summarising key government policies across each risk factor, included in the appendix. See Appendix 1 for an overview of the scope of policies included.

Previous Next